‎By Elias Abayomi Adagunduro, Publisher, Newsconnect Online & President, The Press Society.

For millions of Nigerians, government is not an institution located in Abuja or a distant state capital.

It is the road to the market, the primary healthcare centre in the neighbourhood, the water project in the community, the local school, the drainage system and the infrastructure that determines whether a small business can survive.

That reality makes Nigeria’s 774 local government areas central to one of the country’s most important economic questions:

‎Can financial autonomy transform local governments into engines of grassroots development and inclusive economic growth?

The question gained renewed significance following the Supreme Court’s landmark July 11, 2024 judgment on local government financial autonomy.

The judgment was widely regarded as a major intervention in Nigeria’s federal system and the long-running debate over the financial independence of local councils.

‎But a legal victory is only the beginning.

The more important question for ordinary Nigerians is whether autonomy will translate into better roads, functioning markets, improved healthcare, stronger local businesses, employment opportunities and better living conditions.

In other words, will money reaching the local government translate into value reaching the people?

From courtroom victory to economic reality

‎Local governments are the tier of government closest to Nigerians.

They operate at the point where public policy meets everyday economic activity.
‎A farmer does not experience economic policy only through federal budgets. The farmer also experiences it through the condition of the road linking the farm to the market.

A trader does not experience government only through national monetary policy. The trader also experiences it through the condition of the market, sanitation, security and accessibility.

‎For a small enterprise, an unreliable local road can increase transportation costs. Poor drainage can damage goods. Inadequate public infrastructure can increase operating expenses.

This makes local government finance an economic issue.

The question of who controls local government resources is therefore also a question about who has the capacity to influence economic conditions at the grassroots.

The promise of financial autonomy

The Supreme Court’s July 11, 2024 judgment brought the issue of local government financial autonomy into sharper focus.

The Federal Government had challenged the arrangements under which state governments exercised significant control over local government funds through the State-Local Government Joint Account.

The Supreme Court’s intervention reinforced the principle that local governments should have greater financial independence.

The expectation among supporters of the reform was that greater control over their resources would enable councils to respond more directly to the needs of their communities.

But financial autonomy is not synonymous with good governance.

A local government can have access to money and still fail to produce meaningful development.That is why the next phase of the debate must move from allocation to accountability.

The ₦14 billion question in Amuwo-Odofin

One case illustrates why that distinction matters.

In Amuwo-Odofin Local Government Area of Lagos State, questions were raised over the utilisation of funds reportedly received by the council.

A former chairman questioned the incumbent in respect to local government’s handling of what was reported as about ₦14 billion in federal allocations.

The issue was framed around whether the resources received by the council had been judiciously utilised and whether the level of development in the area reflected the resources reportedly available to the local government.

The allegation itself should not be treated as proof of financial misconduct.

Rather, it raises a question that should be asked of every local government in Nigeria:

When substantial public resources are allocated to a council, what measurable value does the community receive in return?

The Amuwo-Odofin example is important precisely because it shifts the conversation away from abstract figures.

Money allocated to a local government ultimately belongs to the public.

Citizens therefore have a legitimate interest in knowing how much was received, what it was spent on, which projects were executed, how much those projects cost and whether they are delivering the promised benefits.

The lesson extends beyond Amuwo-Odofin.

If a council receives substantial allocations but residents cannot identify corresponding improvements in infrastructure and services, questions of transparency and accountability inevitably arise.

‎The real value of ₦14 billion

The economic significance of such an allocation should not be measured only by its size.

The bigger question is what such resources can accomplish.

Properly planned and transparently deployed, public funds can support infrastructure and services that improve the economic environment.

Better roads can reduce transportation difficulties.

Functional markets can support traders.

Drainage and sanitation can protect businesses and communities.

Healthcare investment can reduce the economic burden of illness.

Community infrastructure can make local areas more attractive for investment and enterprise.

‎The opposite is also true.

When public resources are poorly managed, communities lose not just money but opportunities.

A project that is abandoned represents money spent without corresponding public value.

‎A road that remains impassable represents additional transportation costs.

A market that deteriorates can constrain commercial activity.

The economic cost of weak local governance is therefore borne by citizens and businesses.

The politics of who governs

But money is only one part of the problem.

The quality of people who emerge to manage local government resources matters equally.

Grassroots politics in Nigeria can be expensive.

Candidates may have to purchase party nomination forms, mobilise supporters, campaign and compete within political structures where financial resources can play a significant role.

These costs can discourage citizens who may have the competence, empathy and commitment to serve but lack the financial resources required to compete.

This raises a difficult question:

If political participation increasingly depends on financial capacity, are some of Nigeria’s best potential grassroots leaders being kept outside the political systems.

Political patronage and godfatherism further complicate the situation.

Candidates who depend heavily on powerful political sponsors can face competing obligations once they assume office.

Their constitutional and democratic responsibility is to the people.

But political debts can create pressures that have little connection with good governance.

This is not an assertion that every politician backed by a political leader is incapable of delivering good governance.

Rather, it highlights the need for a political environment where competence, character, community credibility and policy proposals can compete meaningfully with money and patronage.

The cost to the local economy.

The consequences are economic.

A local government that spends its resources efficiently can help create an environment where businesses operate more effectively.

A poorly managed local government can compound existing economic pressures.

Nigeria is already dealing with inflation, high transportation costs, energy challenges, unemployment and reduced household purchasing power.

For small businesses and low-income households, these pressures are particularly severe.

Local governments cannot solve all of Nigeria’s macroeconomic problems.

‎

‎They do, however, have a role in providing services and infrastructure within their areas of responsibility that can reduce some of the costs confronting residents.

This is why local government autonomy should be assessed as an economic reform as well as a constitutional one.

Autonomy without accountability is not enough.

There is a danger in assuming that transferring financial control automatically produces development.

It does not.

If financial autonomy simply means that local officials have greater control over public resources without stronger transparency and oversight, the reform could fail to achieve its intended purpose.

Autonomy must therefore be accompanied by accountability.

Citizens should be able to access information about local government revenue and expenditure.

Budgets should be transparent.
Procurement should follow established rules.Projects should be publicly identifiable. Audits should be meaningful. Community members should be able to question elected officials. Journalists and civil society organisations should be able to investigate and report on local government spending.

These safeguards are not obstacles to autonomy. They are what make autonomy meaningful.

The 774-local-government opportunity

Nigeria’s 774 local governments collectively represent an enormous development opportunity.

Even modest improvements across hundreds of councils could have a significant cumulative effect.

Consider a situation where local governments systematically invest in infrastructure that supports economic activity.

Farm-to-market roads could reduce logistical challenges.

Improved markets could support traders and small enterprises.

Water and sanitation infrastructure could improve public health and productivity.

Better community-level healthcare could reduce the financial burden of preventable illnesses.

Skills and youth-development initiatives could help people participate more effectively in the economy.

The objective should not be to turn every local government into a giant economic institution.

It should be to ensure that each council uses available resources efficiently to perform its responsibilities and create conditions that enable residents and businesses to prosper.

The subsidy-removal dimension

The economic importance of local government effectiveness became even more pronounced following the removal of petrol subsidies.

The Federal Government presented subsidy removal as a major fiscal reform intended to reduce the burden of subsidy payments on public finances and redirect resources toward other priorities.

But the policy also contributed to a significant increase in transportation and living costs.

For households and businesses already under pressure, functioning local infrastructure can make an important difference.

A farmer who spends less moving produce can retain more income.

A trader who operates in a functional market faces fewer infrastructure-related obstacles.

A small business that has access to basic public infrastructure can devote more resources to productive activity.

However, it would be misleading to suggest that local government autonomy alone can resolve the economic consequences of subsidy removal.

Nigeria’s economic difficulties are driven by several factors, including inflation, exchange-rate pressures, energy costs, productivity constraints and broader structural weaknesses.

Local government reform is therefore one component of a much larger economic transformation agenda.

The implementation test

The Supreme Court judgment created an opportunity.

But implementation remains the decisive issue.

The existence of elected local councils is not, by itself, evidence that financial autonomy has produced economic development.

The true test is whether councils can independently and transparently manage resources and whether citizens can identify measurable improvements.

This is why cases such as the questions raised in Amuwo-Odofin deserve attention.

They provide an opportunity to ask what financial autonomy should look like in practice.

If a local government receives billions of naira, residents should be able to see evidence of responsible expenditure.

If a council receives less, it should still be accountable for every naira available to it.

The principle is simple:

‎Public resources must produce public value.

A new generation of grassroots leadership.

Nigeria also needs to address the political barriers that discourage capable citizens from participating.

A country seeking sustainable economic development cannot afford to have grassroots politics dominated exclusively by those with the deepest pockets.

Political parties must create room for competent citizens.

Electoral processes must encourage credible competition. Citizens must become more interested in the records and programmes of candidates rather than simply their political connections. And elected officials must understand that political office is a public trust, not an investment to be recovered.

The emergence of capable local leaders could have an economic multiplier effect.

Competent leadership can improve planning.

Better planning can improve spending.

Better spending can improve infrastructure and services.

Improved infrastructure can support businesses.

Stronger businesses can create jobs and increase household incomes.

That is how political reform can eventually become economic reform.

From allocation to accountability

The central issue confronting Nigeria’s local government system is therefore no longer simply whether councils should have financial autonomy.

The more difficult question is:

What will they do with it?

The ₦14 billion question raised in Amuwo-Odofin is a useful reminder that large allocations must be followed by equally large expectations of accountability.

The answer should not be political accusations without evidence.

It should be transparency.

Let the figures be published.

Let expenditure be explained.

Let projects be identified.

Let communities inspect them.

Let auditors do their work.

Let journalists investigate.

Let citizens ask questions.

And let elected officials account for the resources entrusted to them.

The economic future may begin locally

Nigeria’s economic transformation will not happen only through major federal projects or international investments.

It will also happen in communities.

It will happen when a farmer can move produce to market at lower cost.

When a trader can operate in a decent market.

When a young entrepreneur can build a business without being crippled by avoidable infrastructure costs.

When families have access to basic services.

When public resources are deployed transparently.

And when citizens can hold leaders accountable.

The Supreme Court’s July 11, 2024 judgment created an opportunity to rethink the relationship between local government finance and grassroots development.

But autonomy is only the beginning.

The real victory will come when financial independence produces accountable governance, productive communities and measurable economic value.

Nigeria has 774 local government areas.

That is not merely a political statistic.

It is 774 opportunities to bring development closer to the people.

The question is whether the country will seize them.

For the Driving Growth and Business Economy Journalist Award, that is the fundamental issue this investigation seeks to place before the public:

Can Nigeria turn local government financial autonomy from a constitutional promise into an economic dividend for the people?

The answer will not be found in the size of allocations alone.

It will be found in what those allocations become—in roads, markets, healthcare, livelihoods, businesses, jobs and improved communities.

Ultimately, the measure of public finance is not how much government receives.

It is how much value the people receive in return.


‎

By News Connect Online

News Connect Online is a grassroot advocacy news platform established to promote development and peace through efficient and effective reportage across all beats. Beat: Education, Entertainment Environment Energy Business Health, Sport, Foreign News, Advocacy, Tourism, Transportation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *