Employers’ body, government agencies and tobacco operators warn of conflicting laws, rising business costs; demand review of proposed legislation

A proposed bill seeking to expand the regulatory framework for food, medical and related products has triggered opposition from the Nigeria Employers’ Consultative Association (NECA), the Standards Organisation of Nigeria (SON), the Federal Ministry of Health and Social Welfare, and tobacco industry operators over fears of overlapping mandates, conflicting laws and potential disruption to legitimate businesses.

The stakeholders have urged the National Assembly to reconsider provisions of the proposed Food, Medical Products and Related Products (Registration, Etc.) Bill, 2026, with NECA specifically calling for tobacco products to be excluded from the legislation.

In its formal submission to the Senate Committee on Health, NECA warned that the Bill could introduce unnecessary regulatory complications into an industry already subject to existing laws and multiple regulatory controls.

Sponsored by Senator Umar Sadiq Suleiman, the Bill passed second reading in the Senate on July 21, 2026. It seeks to repeal the Food, Drugs and Related Products Act, 2004, and establish a new regulatory framework for food, medical and related products.

However, NECA argued that extending the proposed framework to tobacco products could conflict with the National Tobacco Control Act, 2015, the National Tobacco Control Regulations, 2019, and the Standards Organisation of Nigeria Act, 2015.

The employers’ association warned that the proposed legislation could create overlapping responsibilities among the National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control (NAFDAC), the Federal Ministry of Health and Social Welfare, SON and the Nigeria Customs Service.

According to NECA, such duplication could result in multiple product-registration requirements, repeated approvals, conflicting enforcement decisions, higher compliance costs and uncertainty for legitimate businesses.

The association maintained that tobacco products belong to a distinct regulatory category and should not be treated as food or medicines under the proposed law.

It further argued that NAFDAC’s existing statutory mandate does not expressly cover tobacco products, warning that their inclusion in the Bill could extend the agency’s authority into an area already governed by dedicated legislation.

NECA also raised concerns about provisions that would grant additional powers over product registration, suspension, seizure, factory operations and enforcement, arguing that these could conflict with the established responsibilities of other regulatory institutions.

Of particular concern is the proposed ceiling-list mechanism, which NECA believes could grant NAFDAC excessive administrative discretion to restrict products without adequate statutory safeguards and oversight.

The association consequently called on lawmakers to exclude tobacco products from the Bill, introduce safeguards against unilateral regulatory decisions and strengthen coordination among existing government agencies.

It stressed that effective regulation should be based on clearly defined institutional responsibilities, predictable compliance requirements, proportionate enforcement and coordination among relevant agencies.

NECA also urged the National Assembly to ensure that the proposed legislation complements, rather than contradicts, Nigeria’s existing tobacco-control framework.

The association expressed its willingness to continue engaging with lawmakers and other stakeholders to achieve a balanced legislative outcome that protects public health while preserving regulatory certainty and business confidence.

Health Ministry Warns Against Conflicting Mandates

The Federal Ministry of Health and Social Welfare, which supervises NAFDAC, also expressed strong reservations about the proposed amendments during the public hearing.

Representing the ministry, Dr Adebisi Adegoke, mni, Director of Hospital Services, highlighted the potential for regulatory conflicts, duplication and overlapping mandates, warning that such developments would not present the government in a good light.

The ministry recommended that consideration of the Bill be deferred to allow further consultations with affected stakeholders and ensure full alignment with the Ministry of Health and Social Welfare.

SON Aligns With Health Ministry, Seeks Deferment

The Standards Organisation of Nigeria also raised objections to provisions it said could conflict with the SON Act and interfere with its established statutory responsibilities.

At the public hearing, SON aligned with the Health Ministry’s position, calling for the Bill to be deferred to allow for a more comprehensive review that would eliminate unnecessary complexities and overlapping mandates.

The organisation also expressed concern that adequate stakeholder engagement and consultation might not have taken place before the proposed amendments were introduced.

Tobacco Industry Raises Alarm Over Business Disruption

Tobacco industry operators have similarly warned that introducing an additional regulatory layer could complicate compliance without necessarily improving regulatory effectiveness.

During a recent public hearing on the proposed legislation, industry stakeholders maintained that tobacco manufacturing, importation, distribution, packaging, health warnings, product standards and related activities are already subject to extensive statutory controls.

They argued that parallel approval and enforcement structures could expose legitimate manufacturers and importers to conflicting directives, additional administrative expenses, operational disruptions and uncertainty over which agency has the final regulatory authority.

The operators maintained that their concerns should not be interpreted as opposition to public-health regulation, but as a warning against multiplying regulatory requirements without clearly demonstrated public-policy benefits.

They further argued that unpredictable compliance obligations could weaken investor confidence, discourage business expansion and undermine the Federal Government’s efforts to improve Nigeria’s competitiveness and ease of doing business.

Industry stakeholders also warned that imposing unnecessary administrative burdens on compliant businesses could divert regulatory attention and resources from more pressing enforcement challenges, particularly illicit trade and non-compliant operators.

The submissions by NECA, the Health Ministry, SON and tobacco industry operators have placed regulatory coordination and the scope of NAFDAC’s proposed authority at the centre of the debate surrounding the Bill.

The National Assembly is being urged to address the concerns through further consultation and legislative review to prevent conflicting mandates while maintaining effective public-health safeguards and a predictable business environment.

By News Connect Online

News Connect Online is a grassroot advocacy news platform established to promote development and peace through efficient and effective reportage across all beats. Beat: Education, Entertainment Environment Energy Business Health, Sport, Foreign News, Advocacy, Tourism, Transportation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *